I was recently asked two questions in a public forum that caught me so off guard that I didn’t answer them the way I should have. 

The questions were:

  1. Are you religious?
  2. Do you believe in God?

These questions are particularly loaded to a Saudi or to a Muslim – whether by birth or belief – in today’s world.

Much modern discourse relies on a dichotomy between a monolithic “West” and an even more monolithic “Islam”.  I wholeheartedly and wholemindedly do not buy into this paradigm, which among other problems, oversimplifies and dehistoricises a much more complex world. (If you haven’t already read Orientalism and the many studies it has inspired, please do.)

But whether I like it or not, I have to learn to survive within the paradigm so that I can live to overthrow it. In it, if you admit to being religious, that admission risks alienating you from a Western audience (and compromising your ability to get visas). If you admit to not being religious, that admission risks alienating you from your Muslim audience (and compromising your ability to go home).

An even more dangerous question than, “Are you religious?” is, “Do you believe in God?” If you are born Muslim, there is only one answer to this question that will not get you killed.*

When asked, I should have said that I risked losing too much by trying to answer these two ostensibly harmless questions. I can’t take back my response, but I can write about what I wish I had said.

There’s a wonderful French phrase for the moment you think of that witty response you should have used in a conversation gone by: l’esprit de l’escalier, “the wit of the staircase”. Because by the time you are clear-headed enough to come up with a response, you have arrived to the bottom of the staircase that led away from the time and place of the original conversation.

*Deeyah Khan, an award-winning documentary maker, explores the dangers and threats that ex-Muslims face in “Exposure: Islam’s Non-Believers”.

2 thoughts on ““Are you religious?”

  1. I very much agree with you on how hard it is to answer these two questions. People tend to have ready-made jugments on your spiritual orientations by your appearance. Especially if you are a Saudi woman. so either you are religious by default because you “look” like one, or you’re not because you don’t!!
    I would add that parents have another difficult question to deal with when it comes to religion. What do we tell our children? and how do we raise them to embrace their own beliefs if we are too afraid to do that ourselves! Especially if parents don’t seem to agree on this subject, or if one of them is keeping their true beliefs to themselves for the sake of their children!!

    thank you for this thought provoking post!

    Like

    1. Thank you for your thoughtful comment! You’re so right. Being a Saudi woman comes with a host of assumptions about religiosity, modesty, beliefs, and even personality. And I would say the same goes when someone is labeled a Muslim. There seems to be only one way to be Muslim in the eyes of the “other” – and that is to be a practicing, devout, perhaps fanatical Muslim.

      And your point about what to share with we can share with our children if our beliefs are our own. Both Islam and others’ views of Islam seem to rob Muslims of any choice! Thank you again for raising these important points!

      P.S. Apologies for my delayed reply (manic week)!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s